Can you make someone get help with their mental health? | Episode 4 #AskMind
Lucy from Mind’s information team answers one of the hardest questions we get on our helpline, ‘Can you make someone get help?’
For more information go to http://www.mind.org.uk/askmind
Hello and welcome to Episode 4 of Ask Mind. I’m Lucy from Mind’s information team.
It’s mine and my team’s job to write all of the information on Mind’s website – we answer the calls, emails and texts which come through on our helpline and generally do all we can to make sure people are know how to navigate the mental health system and to cope with their mental health problems.
Today we’re going to answer another common question that we get: Can you make someone get help with their mental health?
And it’s a really tough one, because unfortunately, the answer isn’t always what people want to hear.
Because the truth is, that no, in most cases you can’t make someone get help if they don’t want it.
If you feel that someone you love is clearly struggling but can’t or won’t reach out for help, and won’t accept any help you offer, it’s understandable to feel frustrated, worried, powerless…
Especially if you think they are at risk, sitting by and doing nothing just does not feel like an option.
But although it’s really difficult, they are an individual, and even if you don’t agree with their choices, they do have a right to decide how they deal with things.
You can’t:
• Force someone to talk to you. It’s not easy talking about mental health problems. And putting pressure on someone or making them feel they are not in control of their own situation is only going to make them feel more uncomfortable and alone.
• You can’t normally force someone to get help. As adults, we are all ultimately responsible for making our own decisions. This includes when – or if – we choose to seek help when we feel unwell.
• You can’t see a health care professional for someone else. A doctor might give you general information about symptoms or diagnoses, but they won’t be able to share any specific advice or details about someone else without their knowledge and agreement.
But there are some things you can do, and while they might feel like not enough, they can really make a huge difference to how someone is feeling and may even help them begin to take steps to getting help:
You can:
1. Be patient. You won’t always know the full story. There may be reasons why they are finding it difficult to ask for help.
2. Let them know how they are feeling is valid and that you are there to talk to without judgement. Let them know you care about them and you’ll be there if they change their mind about asking for help.
3. Show them the ways that they can seek help if and when they’re ready.
4. Look after yourself. Worry and stress can make you unwell too. If you can pay attention to how you’re eating, sleeping and moving about. These are all things that can help us stay well.
There are some exceptions to this. There may be times when you are worried someone is unsafe, either to themselves or to someone else.
They might be feeling they want to seriously hurt or kill themselves.
Or they might be behaving in a way that’s putting themselves or someone else at immediate, serious risk of harm.
In this situation, the quickest way to get help is by calling 999, or going to A&E. We have further info on that on our website, which you can get to by clicking on this pop up I here.
In really exceptional circumstances, it’s possible to keep a person in hospital, or ‘section’ them under a law called the Mental Health Act. This is done without their consent, and often against their will so is very serious, and can only be taken by a team of approved mental health professionals (AMHPs).
If you feel someone is at serious risk and will not approach anyone for help, you can contact their local social services, who can decide to arrange an assessment.
This is a heavy responsibility, so before taking action it’s important that you understand what might happen, and what your loved one’s rights are. We have all you need to know about this process on our website if you think you might need to consider it
So that’s all for now, I hope that’s helped. If it has click ‘like’ and subscribe so you can can keep up to date with the next episode.
If not, why not ask a question for next time? Pop it in the comments below or email us at ask@mind.org.uk
Remember, if you could really do with the information right now, call our Infoline on 0300 123 3393, text them on 86463 or email info@mind.org.uk
Thanks for watching, bye!
18 Comments
You can also force someone into a mental health ward if they are unable to take care of themself (cleanliness)
Good points, it's hard enough changing myself let alone persuading someone else to change. Just being there for me has been some of the best help I have had.
Very informative and very well presented.
I need help at 3am not nine till five. I hear so often professionals say "we didn't know they were suicidal " how do I get it on my medical records, official records, so medical professionals can not wash their hands of me. When I'm gone
anyone looking for some help or just a story to relate too take a look at my channel x
I have a theory on the getting called crazy. It's a little deeper than stigma.
Really great information. Enjoyed this. Thanks for sharing !
I needsome one to talk to , o'm depressed.
Hi everyone!
I hope you're having a lovely day. If you're looking for more mental health related videos, I make chatty advice and friendly videos about mental health, as well as talking about my own experience with anxiety, OCD and eating disorders.
Stop by and say hello if you'd like to!
thank you
Of course…where there's a way there a will, im a psyche major…
If you say an feel can't, you are part of the problem and not the solution…
Psyche mixed Philosophy, both my majors…
Good luck with making someone get help, not on the nhs anyway, there isn’t any to be got. So if you want someone to get help, do you have £60 to £120 per session to pay for it?
Call 999 or go to a and e if you want to be left waiting for hours and be treated with derision and sent home. I know of too many people this has happened to. There is no mental health provision in the nhs. If you ask for help too many times you get blacklisted.
I tried talking to my wife dr about her destructive behavior that was feeding her anti depressants that didn't do anything I spent months combing threw things trying to figure out what to do and what would help to the point i had not being a dr narrowed it down to what the problems were from the symptoms BPD when i tried to talk to her dr and tell her what i was observing i went unheard i was givin a big line about hepa and that she could talk to me or tell me info about my wife i told this dr im not trying to get info im trying to tell you what i see and live threw ever single day that you spend 10 min ask simple questions hand her some pills and then push her on out the door and move to the next person my wife one day grab my 1 year old and ran with her havent seen them since i went threw ever thing i could to try to get someone to listen that she was self harming and nothing so ya i live with the fact she is not right i live with the fact that one day my daughter will have problems because her mom would not get help before you say you cant help anyone because there a person to you should remember that there many times are children involved that dont deserve this sounds to me like a never ending cycle that keeps lining the pockets of the system that dont do anything i can only hope that one day something changes but i dont think it will
Can you MAKE someone get … help?? Can you force someone who doesn't want to stay married to go to couple's counseling? Can you force someone who doesn't want to become an engineer to remain an engineering major? Too much obsessing in our culture about controlling other people's personal choices. No one (at least adults) should HAVE to take up any medical intervention others think is right.
You can help people that want to help themselves. Plain and simple.