Why Will Doctors Rarely Prescribe Behavioral Change?
Check out Dr. K’s Guide to Mental Health: https://bit.ly/3GaubzI
Our Healthy Gamer Coaches have transformed over 10,000 lives. Be the next success story: https://bit.ly/3yK93vH
Dr. K’s Guide to Mental Health explores Anxiety, Depression, ADHD, and Meditation with 150+ video chapters in a Final Fantasy-inspired skilltree.
#shorts #drk #mentalhealth
43 Comments
For sure! I want that magic pill that cures everything. 😂
Except that exercise and diet don't lower insulin resistance and the weight comes back as soon as you stop. Ozempic does.
Don't dismiss medication like this. It's not just easier for the doctor to prescribe, it's also easier, if not downright doable for the patient. Someone who has a full time job and possibly a family doesn't have the energy or the time to do 90 minutes of aerobic exercise five days a week that are needed to have any impact on insulin resistance.
Also, if I had a penny for every response that said "you can't" each time someone asked if they could treat their ADHD with supplements, I'd be rich. This "big pharma is making money off of us" mentality actually hurts those people as they keep wasting their lives trying out things that do not work while they have extremely effective meds at their disposal. Sure, exercise helps, but you need to be able to actually have motivation to exercise regularly, and not get bored of it after a month.
The reason for a pharmacology based medical system, is simpler than that… There is NO money in genuine Health – only in ongoing disease.
For the majority of history, finding an easy way to work less was evolutionary advantageous (even now it gets rewarded). Consuming salt, fat, and sugar was evolutionary advantageous. A solution needs to be implemented at a societal level instead of just shaming people for following their biological programming.
Dr diet first and you'll get better results. Do both to yield optimum results.
I saw a meme of a doctor telling his patient "all your health problems can be fixed with a healthier diet and exercise. Here take these pills"
It's the talk of what can be seen with eyes/materials that's sustaining the system to continue maximising profit.
There’s no money in healing just making people more sick makes money! I’ve disagreed with this approach my entire life. Doctors could change this.
True.👍👍
Correct 1000%!
Honestly, if a doc ACTUALLY takes the time to not just explain this, but help me set up such things. Then I wouldn't be so disappointed in the current system.
Patients don’t want to hear it and don’t want to do it. I’m a retired physician and I can confirm, patients do not take that advice, when offered.
Actually trillions of dollars are invested into behavioral change. It is called "school" and "eduucation". And we all are results of such a behavioral change. But "somehow" it is not the change we want or benefit of.
There is another problem here. Diet and exercise are not intuitive for a lot of people. They need help learning how to eat healthy, they need to be taught how to exercise with proper form to prevent injury. Some people need that professional support to help them get started, or even keep going when times get difficult.
However, dietitians and personal trainers are EXPENSIVE to hire out of pocket. Personal trainers and gym memberships aren't covered by insurance, and dietitians are only sometimes covered.
So it's not only a "people won't do it." That is definitely happening, but there is also "people aren't being taught how."
Yeah, they could go to the internet for help, try to learn themselves, but there is so much conflicting information out there, and DANGEROUS information out there. Additionally, they still wouldn't have that extra support that another human being can bring them when they need help.
Dr. K, I would love to see you interview Dr. Mike Israetel! He has a lot of things he could be challenged on that I think you might be able to unpack
Yeah but healthy lifestyle changes don't makepharma and insurance companies rich so they lobby doctors and policy makers to push pharmacology and other expensive treatments rather than actually help people make real change.
I hear you. And granted this is a short. Nonetheless, the US food system is not individual behavior based. Systemic change for my body, yes. Also, systemic change for society, and if not Ozempic might be the thing that helps people break the addiction to the warped system while they do the hard work of learning the system and then then make better choices. Let's not guilt people for pits they didn't choose to fall into, dug by more powerful people who knew better and did it anyway.
Investment in behavioral change is mostly lost money. Any basic investir, or even doctor can tell that. Forcing people to change their behaviors without willingness is lost cause.
The body needs to move. Exercise is very important.
That and now it’s politically correct to say things like health at every size even if that size is nearly immobile
Theres no $ incentive to get people actually healthy
Look at that beauuutiful skin!! 👀🤩
maybe if someone did a study to prove how behavioural changes could make profit.. then they would invest in behavioural change
This is why I'm looking forward to Kennedy getting confirmed for HHS. He's been an advocate for this for years.
Thank you for being more attention to this situation!
So true and it so sad😢
hard yes but I'd say the more likely primary reason is that people make more money from selling you drugs than they do from telling you to be healthy.
Sincerely GO ROLLERSKATING! It's exercise that is actually fun.
Remember when we used to go outside? When kids would skip rope for hours during recess? When Kindergarten was half day and was about learning social skills? Maybe we should go back to "leaner times"……
When you're busy running around outside you're too busy to feed your face.
Isn't an SSRI just a bridge to "go for a walk and eat some yogurt"? Ozempic is a bridge to "eat less garbage". Chantix for smoking etc.
I feel like there is a lack of emphasis on the bridge aspect of these pharmacological interventions. "I'll give you drug x so you'll adhere to behavior y."
Does behavioral research follow the same pattern of standards as psychopharmacology? Like, Prozac research has a P-value; does DBT?
It’s all about sales taxes profits that’s why preventing doesn’t fill pockets
Its because behavioural change wont make money like medecine
And this honesty and humbleness is why I am a huge fan of you! You operate at a higher dimension bro ❤
diet and exercise are not prioritized because there are no patents and profit to be made
Doctors always recommend behavioral change, we just don’t do it and then go back to get help again so they give us a pill
Diet is probably more important than the other two..
I'd love to be able to exercise. If anyone can come up with an effective exercise regime for somebody with osteoarthritis in their neck, spine and ones, osteoporosis in cervical and lumbar spine, inflammatory arthritis in hands and feet, chronic neck-induced migraines, high blood pressure and vertigo along other issues, hit me up! 🙄
Because you eating healthy and exercising doesn't make anyone rich🙃
I'm 9 days off tobacco and doing some calisthenics feel great 👌
This dude is my fav on YouTube. He’s the best all around advisor
BOOM BOOM BOOM. It's so simple; logical! Behavioral change is how the older generations made it. Oiy@
I don't understand how people consider it ethical to just give pills.