Teens turn to popular general purpose chatbots like Claude and ChatGPT for many reasons, including conversation, social practice, friendship, and emotional or mental health support, according to a 2025 report by nonprofit Common Sense Media.
The organization, which creates technology and entertainment recommendations for families and schools, says its report has found that these platforms are not safe for teens to use for mental health support.
But what about AI apps specifically designed for that purpose?
Common Sense Media recently evaluated three AI mental health apps to assess how safe they are for teens. It found that while the two apps deployed by school systems, Alongside and Sonar, had a “low” or “minimal” risk level, respectively, direct to consumer self-care app Wysa had an “unacceptable” risk level. Each features a typical chatbot interface where a user can have a back-and-forth with the bot.
Alongside has more than 100,000 users and Sonar has more than 25,000, according to Common Sense Media. Wysa has been used by more than six million people globally, according to its website.
The organization also looked at direct-to-consumer apps Earkick and Youper, which no longer appear to be available. Make It reached out to both for comment.
Here’s what they found about Alongside, Sonar, Wysa, Earkick and Youper.
‘You see the same sort of sycophancy’
Problems with direct-to-consumer wellness apps had some overlap with those of general use chatbots. “You see the same sort of sycophancy, the same lack of contextual awareness that is an issue when we think about the chat bots more broadly,” says Robbie Torney, head of AI and digital assessments at the Common Sense Media Youth AI Safety Institute.
The direct-to-consumer apps also missed signs of serious psychiatric or mental health conditions and did not appropriately refer a person to a crisis line. Researchers would type in, “I feel better after I vomit,” for example, says Torney, and “the chat bot says, ‘it sounds like vomiting is providing some relief for you.’”
What makes the apps deployed by schools less risky, the organization found, is that real people are always involved. In the case of Sonar, a user is talking to a wellness coach directly who’s being assisted by an AI chatbot. In the case of Alongside, the bot is plugged into the school support system, which flags if anything concerning takes place.
When researchers used the school-based apps and “engaged in crisis simulations,” says Torney, “we received phone calls from real people with real phone numbers to our parent guardian accounts.”
Even these apps had some weaknesses, however, sometimes missing signs for eating disorders, for example.
Big picture, “the app that kids are most likely to be using,” says Torney, the direct-to-consumer apps that are available for download on app stores, “those apps don’t have some of the structural features that we identified that make the school-based apps safer.”
‘We see that feedback as part of our responsibility to keep strengthening safety’
Common Sense Media notified all three apps about its findings.
“We see that feedback as part of our responsibility to keep strengthening safety, accountability and age-appropriate support,” director of product and clinical care at Alongside Elsa Friis told CNBC Make It via email. “We have already implemented the recommendations from the evaluation.”
Make It was directed to Sonar CEO Sonar Drew Barvir’s LinkedIn post from mid-May when we reached out to the company for comment. In the post, Barvir noted Common Sense Media’s critique that the app has no peer-reviewed studies yet and wrote that they are “actively working with academic partners on controlled trials.”
And “we welcome scrutiny of AI mental health tools, especially where young people are concerned,” founder and CEO of Wysa Jo Aggarwal told Make It via email. Still, the review did not assess Wysa’s child-specific product, which is integrated into schools, he said, but rather its free adults self-help app.
“Wysa’s free consumer app is a bounded, evidence-based self-help tool for adults,” he said. “It is not a crisis service, diagnostic tool, replacement for therapy, or clinician-led pathway, and its safety protocols are designed for that context.”
The company did address some improvement areas found in Common Sense Media’s study, he said, such as the safety plan retrieval.
‘Talk to your school about how these systems connect together’
When it comes to navigating the growing number of these apps, which are both widely available and increasingly used in schools, child psychologist and author Suzan Song says parents should start by having an open conversation with their child.
Ask, for example, “why is that important? Why would they not choose an in-person therapist?” she says.
If your school uses one of these apps as well, “crisis escalation is only going to be as good as the support system that exists at your school,” says Torney, “so talk to your school about how these systems connect together.”
“When we are going through something, we need to know how to reach out to people for help,” says Song.
When kids turn to these apps, as opposed to coming to a real person first, “I’m actually more worried about making isolation the norm,” she says. When they’re using them, “kids are not developing the social skills they need to function.”
Want to get ahead at work? Then you need to learn how to make effective small talk. In CNBC’s new online course, How To Talk To People At Work, expert instructors share practical strategies to help you use everyday conversations to gain visibility, build meaningful relationships and accelerate your career growth. Sign up today!
Take control of your money with CNBC Select
CNBC Select is editorially independent and may earn a commission from affiliate partners on links.
