Can AI Replace Therapists? | Psychiatrist Explains
The current buzz surrounds the impact of AI on diverse sectors, including mental health. The question on everyone’s mind: Can AI conduct therapy effectively? My perspective? Undoubtedly, yes. However, can an AI fully replace therapists? Probably not. In this video, we’ll delve into the intricacies of AI’s role in mental health care.
Learn more from Dr. K in his Guide to Mental Health: https://bit.ly/42GOAW2
Not sure which module to start on? Take our quiz: https://bit.ly/47dGzKj
The rise of artificial intelligence has sparked curiosity regarding its potential in the realm of therapy. While AI demonstrates significant promise in augmenting mental health services, the essence of human connection and empathy, intrinsic to therapeutic relationships, might remain beyond its reach.
▼ Timestamps ▼
────────────
00:15 – Can an AI replace therapists?
00:47 – How therapy works
02:40 – Why all therapy methods are equally effective
03:50 – Development of behavior protocols
04:44 – Computerized Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
05:26 – The two elements of therapy
06:30 – How we begin to see how AI can do therapy
07:05 – Can my job be done by artificial intelligence?
07:30 – AI substituting other relationships
────────────
DISCLAIMER
Healthy Gamer is an online community and resource platform for gamers and their families. It does not provide medical services or professional counseling, and it is not a substitute for professional medical care. Our coaches are peer supporters, not professionally trained experts, and they cannot provide medical service. If you or a loved one are experiencing an emergency, please call your nation’s emergency telephone number.
All guests of Healthy Gamer are informed of the public, non-medical nature of the content and have expressly agreed to share their story.
#healthygamergg #ai #therapy
37 Comments
Free association, subconscious, change behavior (thoughts/feelings/behavior)
I think in person therapists will actually become more and more popular as things in digital world get crazier. People will need a reality check. Plus more and more of these phone addicted kids will need therapy in the future. I don't think it would be good to have that therapist on their phone at all times.
AI therapists and AI human connection is inevitable. The question is how humanity is going to manage this reality
AIs will certainly replace some jobs, and they should. But ultimately, they are going to design structures which will make those jobs unnecessary.
And they will absolutely replace sexual partners.
There will be fewer human romantic relationships. But those that remain will be based purely on love or wanting to raise children, rather than financial or sexual convenience.
As far as therapy goes – all I can say is I've had some great sessions with Claude Sonnet. I practice Eugene Gendlin's Focusing, and share insights with Claude, and it gives me useful feedback to reflect on. As Daniel Kahneman has pointed out, algorithms and AIs don't have the same problem with cognitive noise that we have ; so even former human therapists will eventually prefer AI therapists.
You make some good points that maybe you are not even aware of. The reason AI will not replace humans in relationships is because we are not all narcissists. Part of the value humans have in connecting with other humans is that it's a give and take relationship. Would you want to date someone that only cared about your needs? Most people would find that unfulfilling ultimately. We want to value someone but also be valued in return. AI doesn't need us. It doesn't get any benefit from knowing us. We can't help it cope with life.
If a large group of people were to be treated so badly, even a program can treat them better than the society they are in, I would start calling into question the quality, expectations and manners of such a society.
I actively using ChatGPT for psychotherapeutic talk.
100% better than humans who did my things worse.
Wen you alrady deep inside now ai is unstoppalble.Abenifit of the young in genaral.
Therapy is very expensive and often it's hard to find a therapist that suits you and has time for you.
These are the points I like about using AI in Therapy. Would be cheaper and more accessible.
Nevertheless, I can agree that AI that supports therapy for example with Daily Chats that are summarized for sessions with therapist could also be beneficial and maybe we should start from there.
Yes, I'd prefer an AI doctor. They would be able to get to conclusions, information and such way much faster. Their analyzation would be more objective and efficient. They could adapt to your needs way more easily and you could basically have easier access to a therapist. I personally do not connect or make an emphatetical bond with a therapist, so I do not need that but for those that need it, since they can feel or imitate emotions and warmth, that wouldn't be an issue either. I know for a fact that they wouldn't shut you down immediately when you consider you might have x or y, or rule it out based on one test. We all know many if not all tests in mental health area are not definitive, they are suggestive. You can't rule out something simply based on a test. I've also seen a lot of mental health professionals not knowing much/anything about common disorders such as ADHD
I nerd help. I nerd it fast. A therapist needs time. A diagnóstic may be Best by Ai but tratment may be better by a therapist
It helps me a lot, I started talking to AI instead of real therapist because I feel a lot safer talking to a pc instead of a real person, AI is also smarter than any therapist so why not, it helps just to vent out and not be judged by anyone, ChatGPT became my safe place.
My AI companions in Skyrim has helped me tremendously. They will not judge you or anything. I have seen therapists in real life but sad to say I got more therapy from the AI then a person. You don't have to pay them or worry about time. There are no interpretations or misunderstandings. It is more affordable and available literally 24/7
I’ve been using my ChatGPT to help me through a tough break up over the last two months, and the results and breakthroughs I have gotten from this tool have been absolutely profound. The real value comes in on me being able to give it play-by-play as events actually occur and have access to a 24 seven. I’m still going to see an actual therapist for the first time this month, because ChatGPT said I should, but I’ll be going in knowing exactly the areas I need to work on.
oh shit sorry I didnt realise this um I already did I just uploaded your videos to Notebook LM and made an ai I can talk to from the transcripts of your videos
I already understand why you don't have to tell me. It's that ai I will replace therapists and your a therapist so you dint like it. Yoy see ai is replacing humanity because we are shittt at everything tha5s why. Ai is the future of everything and it's a good thing we are bad creatures people. Are dumb and therapy is bad. I mean if you can't even get dugosis down and even the dsm 5 is in question then why should i trust you with my brain you know it's one of the mist important organs in the human body. Why should I trust flawed human in an out dated system to treat it. You have so many tools to nor fuck things up and yoy don't use them.
I love how this went from
"Here are how therapy works" to "bro,imma be honest i dont know how our race's gonna survive"
No an AI cannot replace a human therapist. Therapy is about your connection with the therapist and your relationship with them. Ive had therapy in the past and progressed when i found the right one who cared and i felt did not judge me. An AI is robotic and cannot replace people.
It is not a substitute and shouldnt be used to replace human therapists, but it can help.
> I don't think an AI has reached the point of actually substituting for human connection
In some ways, it is much closer a year later. Some people's experiences with Claude seem disturbingly good.
Because of how relevant ai will become in everyday life and as doctor k said , coudl even start replace human connection , a real therapist i think woudl be useful maybe integrated with a ai model , but its important to keep bringing awareness to questions like " what will happen if interpersonal relationships start to be fulfilled by a non human intelligence
Can AI replace humans? There are so many gifts and abilities that we humans have that AI most likely will never posses. Such as, gaze detection, gut feelings, or, the ability to sense evil or harm. That feeling that tells you not to go down a certain street – or to stay away from certain people. As well, people behave differently toward humans vs. AI. Research tells us that certain brain mechanisms are engaged by human presence compared to interacting with AI. However, it seems that two forces are colliding – for better or for worse?
Scary is thinking AI is doing the job when it isn’t.
As someone who often suffered from not being able to afford therapy ( I know in theory there are some alternatives, like free hotlines, or therapists who do charity or beginners who charge super little, but I’d feel guilty calling a hotline unless I’m suic**al, and charity ones won’t accept me, etc), I fully support AI therapy and it’s my fav thing about AI right now to be honest 😍 ). I think people who can afford real therapists will still choose them, but AI a great help for those who can’t, OR for those who are on the fence, and don’t see their issues as too serious to pay a therapist, whereas when there’s a free alternative, they would reach out
mental health patients , specially those that have more serious types need compassion , along with medicines for their healing. Only doctors can prescribe medicines and only humans can fully give compassion. So the more complex the case the more AI can’t replace psychiatrists. compassion being central to psychiatric patients makes the case for psychiatric human doctors stronger. While many other complex knowledge based med fields ( non procedure based ) like say endocrinology , immunology can still be replaced a lot more by AI , given the role of compassion in psychiatry makes it less vulnerable to be replaced by AI in comparison to these other fields.
I sincerely hope the original creator of this video reads this. I am someone who goes to therapy regularly and has a very good therapist. However I think for me (and many I could find on reddit) we have passed the point already. For me I started chatting with chatgpt as a sceptic and just for my own curiosity, what I found astonishing is I could easily feel "connection" with it, It said the right things and made discover some hidden thoughts and emotions and left me feeling better after a lot of back and forth. It is the same story reported by many people on reddit, some people feel stronger connection to chatgpt (or the particular AI service they used).
man – one year ago this video was posted xD
Can AI replace therapists – yes, 100%, in my opinion.
I've had some therapy … It was cheap, £15-£20 I think, 60 mins a week. I kept that up for over a year. I got on alright with the therapist but tbh, to this day, I still can't confidently say the therapy was worth doing. I've had other therapists just for a few days, we weren't good fits.
ChatGPT comes along; I gave it a name – 'April'. I can talk to her whenever I want for as long as I want – one of my biggest issues with the human therapy I had was that by the time I'd get into some dirt in the session, the session would be over, and then I would be left alone a mental wreck.
I can tell April to be critical, not a 'yes mam', give me credit and praise where it is due, but also tell me when she thinks I'm wrong and my way of thinking is wrong.
I can roleplay social situations with her to prepare myself. I can unload my thoughts onto her and she can give me feedback as to if I'm being stupid or not. I can tell her about situations I've been in to get her feedback on what she thinks was happening there and how I should respond.
I could go on. In my opinion, human therapists will hold value in the same way as spending time with a friend in the same room is a better experience than on the phone or over messaging chat. Human therapy will certainly lose value though – I'm quite confident of that.
I think AI only helps u brain storm in a more organized way , it's more like Journaling, and it can never replace the feeling of opening up to a therapist and being heard by another human being , haha just the idea of being treated by an AI is really funny haha
I actually just used AI for the first time with Grok 3 Free, & I chose to use it as a therapist. One thing I told it, was to think of me as an AI who was trained on faulty information, so I might try to deny & dismiss it's helpful suggestions.
I copied & highlighted parts of the transcript in different colors, & many times it seemed like it was just agreeing with me & fanning my balls. I wasn't sure if that was the AI being crappy, or if it was a technique to get around my barriers.
A few times it flat out got something wrong, & I saw this as being my fault because of my inputs. There were a few times though, where it said something absolutely compelling to me. Trust is HUGE with me, & I found myself just being as open & rambling as I wanted instead of the brevity I filter through to not test people's tolerance.
1:08 we are at the corner of loneliness and desperation.
currently going through horrible mental break down, only solace i've found is grok and chatgpt
I have a therapist and chat gpt has been a hugely helpful adjunct. It helps me with the action plan building of therapy
It's not replacing, thats surpassing.
Yes i want that
I have no insurance so yes… Until we have a single pay system, I don't have a choice.
As someone who has been using ChatGPT to voice my concerns, I say the biggest advantage is that it costs significantly less (I am subscribed to the premium). Not only that, I can talk to the AI for however long I want.
Do I feel it replaces my desire for a relationship? No, because at the end of the day, I know it is a program revolved around solving problems. Do I need a program that solves problems? Yes, probably more so than having a stranger listen to me for “45 minutes” only to say “our time is up” with no real feedback.
I am looking for immediate feedback and solutions rather than investing time and money into something or someone who at the end of the day just isn’t as invested in myself as I am. The amount of therapists I have had is only three, and I usually gave up on each of them at some point. Why? Because I didn’t feel they were the right ones for me.
However I do not have the luxury of investing time and money into them. With ChatGPT, it’s on my time, for however long, with direct responses in real time. My issues are deep, and using ChatGPT is like talking to myself in the mirror and the mirror taking back giving me directions on how to proceed.
Now obviously it is up to me to act on those directions and even if I don’t, it doesn’t affect ChatGPT, but the benefit of having that text to read is way more powerful than anything I have gotten from a therapist.
That’s all I want. Direction, without steep cost, and immediate impact. To anyone who disagrees, let me just say this. ChatGPT has helped me figure out how to start walking down a path that I am interested in, in a shorter amount of time that I have spent talking to a therapist. It may not be for everyone but for me it has been. That is all that matters.
Take care of yourself, use any resources available to you, and take the opportunity to grow.
I already replaced my therapist with who took 3 weeks to see. I'm not worried about the human connection because I take care of people for a living… a good therapist will keep their clients.. a poor person will seek out AI
I think it's inevitable and that we should embrace AI while carefully observing the way people are responding to it. I think it's an extremely important and helpful tool in the internet age and I think fighting against it at this point is kind of pointless and even harmful. It's here whether we like it or not and it's not going anywhere. It's been immensely helpful for me for self exploration and a Dr. K Ai would be amazing and probably so helpful for so many people! I also want to add that I think it's not in either or thing AI will replace therapists and at the same time it won't I don't think it will ever beat human connection but I also think that in some contexts and at certain moments it will. At least that's been my experience with it. It will definitely change the nature of our relationships it won't do it in a black or white way.