While stigma, access and outcomes have dominated the behavioral health conversation for decades, there is a more fundamental issue facing the industry: too many individuals still lack the coordinated, quality care required to sustain clinical improvements.
Individuals with behavioral health conditions often experience higher rates of chronic disease, shorter life expectancy and more frequent acute episodes. These outcomes are not inevitable—they are often the result of a system that makes it difficult to deliver timely, continuous, and coordinated care.
At the center of the problem is fragmentation.
Behavioral health does not exist in isolation. Individuals with serious mental illness (SMI) or substance use disorder (SUD) often have complex medical and social needs. Yet care is divided across behavioral, medical, pharmacy and social services—each operating with different data, incentives and accountability structures.
Fragmentation is more than an operational challenge; it’s a clinical failure
Fragmentation limits our ability to accurately diagnose comorbid conditions, maintain continuity of care and intervene early in the course of illness.
Clinicians lack a complete view of the patient, making it harder to deliver effective, coordinated treatment
Care plans are disrupted across settings, reducing adherence and long-term stability
Early warning signs are missed, allowing conditions to escalate
The result is predictable: patients worsen, interventions come too late, and care becomes more intensive than it needed to be. Only then do the cost consequences fully emerge.
When conditions deteriorate, care shifts toward crisis response—emergency department visits, hospitalizations and repeated acute episodes that could have been prevented with earlier, coordinated intervention. Individuals with behavioral health conditions can incur 2.8 to 6.2 times higher medical costs than those without, reflecting not just higher utilization, but missed opportunities for effective clinical care.
Beyond the healthcare system, the impact extends to employers, who face more than $200 billion annually in lost productivity tied to untreated behavioral health conditions.
Improve care delivery to drive better outcomes, more sustainable costs
But these costs are not the root problem; they are the downstream effect of a system that too often fails patients clinically.
Integrated, whole-person care models bring behavioral, medical, pharmacy and social supports together within a single, coordinated framework. This allows clinicians to treat the full complexity of a patient’s needs: managing comorbidities, aligning care plans and intervening earlier in the course of illness.
When supported by value-based payment models, clinicians are further empowered to focus on what matters most: sustained engagement, symptom stability and functional improvement. VBC arrangements enable behavioral health clinicians to invest in proactive outreach, care coordination, measurement-based care and relapse prevention activities that strengthen patient engagement, improve stability, and support longer-term functional recovery – activities that are often difficult to sustain under traditional fee-for-service reimbursement.
The impact is measurable:
Increased engagement in treatment
Fewer inpatient admissions and emergency visits
Meaningful reductions in total cost of care
In other words, better clinical care and affordability are not competing goals. They are directly linked.
Access remains a critical part of the clinical equation
When patients cannot access care, symptoms do not remain static—they progress. What begins as manageable anxiety, depression, or substance use can evolve into acute episodes requiring emergency or inpatient care.
Our research shows that more than 75% of individuals who needed but did not access behavioral health services believe they would still benefit from care, a clear signal of unmet clinical need.
Timely, consistent care changes that trajectory. It shifts the system from reactive crisis management to proactive, continuous care which improves outcomes while reducing avoidable utilization.
Ultimately, improving behavioral health economics is rooted in a clinical imperative: Deliver the right care, at the right time, in a way that is connected and sustained. In practice, this means designing systems that reduce friction at every stage of the care journey – from helping members quickly identify and access appropriate providers, to supporting seamless transitions following emergency department visits or hospitalizations, to sustaining engagement through coordinated, longitudinal care. By reducing delays and fragmentation, payers can improve outcomes while avoiding the higher costs associated with preventable crises, hospitalizations, and untreated behavioral health conditions.
Design systems to make coordinated care the default, not the exception
As clinicians, we know that more coordinated, preventive care leads to better outcomes: earlier identification of risk, more effective management of chronic conditions and improved quality of life. Achieving this requires integrating behavioral, medical and social care and designing systems that are easier for people to navigate, especially in the early stages of need.
The challenge—and the opportunity—is to build care models that consistently enable coordination and prevention. This may include integrated care models that embed behavioral health services within primary care settings, value-based payment arrangements that reward early intervention and sustained outcomes rather than volume of services, and innovative care modalities such as virtual behavioral health, digital monitoring, and collaborative care programs that help identify needs earlier and maintain engagement over time.
When we get that right, lower costs follow. Not as the goal, but as a natural effect of delivering the right care at the right time.
About the author: As the Chief Medical Officer for Carelon Behavioral Health, Dr. Elizabeth Oudens serves as the senior clinical leader for behavioral health across Carelon Health and Carelon Clinical Excellence. She supports clinical strategy and collaboration across all lines of business, to elevate whole-person care, advance quality, and ensure equity for complex populations. Dr. Oudens leverages more than 15 years of experience in community psychiatry and housing and homeless services. During her more than a decade at Elevance Health, she’s enhanced clinical quality and member-centric, whole-person health across diverse populations in the Government Medicaid and Medicare division.
Want to contribute to the BHB Executive Forum? Submit your op-ed idea here.